Current State

Overview

Even though corporate America spends billions of dollars annually on diversity and inclusion (D&I) programs, most companies have made little progress in hiring a diverse workforce. According to a widely cited 2019 study by Coqual, a New York-based think tank, corporate America's efforts to increase diversity are failing due to a reluctance to discuss race in the workplace, according to the study. Following the killing of George Floyd and the countrywide demonstrations against the institutional racism that followed, efforts to expand diversity and inclusion programs gained additional significance.

Retailers such as Walmart and PwC, among others, have declared initiatives to combat economic and racial inequalities, including pledges to boost their diversity and inclusion efforts. Although participation in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields has increased in the twenty-first century, women, racially diverse, and 2SLGBTQIA+ people continue to be underrepresented in STEM. According to statistics, attrition begins in high school and college, when studies show that they are frequently discouraged by disparate treatment, stereotypes, and a lack of role models.

Some attribute the underrepresentation of racially diverse women and 2SLGBTQIA+ people in STEM careers and research positions to not having people that look like them in these roles. In contrast, others attribute it to the difficulties women, racially diverse, and 2SLGBTQIA+ people face in obtaining salaries, promotions, and opportunities for recognition comparable to those received by their male counterparts.

While most observers recognize the need to increase diversity in STEM disciplines, there is disagreement on the most effective means of achieving this aim. According to others, the primary focus should be tackling toxic workplace practices such as sexual harassment and systematic discrimination. Another school of thought holds that the emphasis should be on enhancing the general culture of inclusion in STEM education and careers, such as through the provision of mentorship programs and the promotion of the achievements of those who have traditionally been underrepresented in these fields.

Race

As businesses began to emphasize combating racism and revamping their diversity and inclusion programs, conservatives became more vocal in their criticisms of diversity and inclusion training, with many decrying it as divisive. Moreover, many public opinion polls have revealed a sharp divide in attitudes toward race in the United States among the general public, whether black or white, Republican or Democrat; many experts question whether the shift in attitudes will be sustained in the long run.

Organizations will need to be deliberate about understanding race and racism. They will also need to understand their impact on American work and life if they are to thrive in this century of social responsibility and social justice.

Gender

Several programs have been put in place by the United States government to enhance gender diversity in STEM jobs and opportunities for women in general. Programs like the White House Council on Women, which ensure federal agencies consider the needs of women and girls when developing policies and programs or legislation, and the Agenda for Women, which includes enhancing economic security and expanding access to paid family leave and other workplace benefits for working mothers and women.

2SLGBTQIA+

In addition, employees who identify as 2SLGBTQIA+ are underrepresented in senior management positions. In the United States, around 5% of women and 4% of males identify as 2SLGBTQIA+. However, according to McKinsey, such women account for only 2.3 percent of entry-level employees, 1.6 percent of managers, and an even smaller proportion of those in more senior management positions. In addition, 2SLGBTQIA+ males account for just 3.1 percent of entry-level employees, 1.9 percent of vice presidency roles, and 2.9 percent of C-suite positions in Fortune 500 companies.